Lauren Spencer, Executive Producer WNBC Sports
George Steinbrenner laid down the gauntlet over the weekend, and issued an ultimatum to New York Yankees manager Joe Torre. Advance past Cleveland in the ALDS or you’re out as Yankee manager.
But the Yankees couldn’t get past the Indians. Chien-Ming Wang’s sinkerballs didn’t sink. The Yankees’ bats went ice cold and a mysterious swarm of midges upended them at Jacobs Field. It all added up to another first round exit by the Yankees and Torre’s almost certain departure.
Yankees fans are now playing the waiting game as the Tampa brass gathers to decide Joe’s fate. The second winningest manager in Yankee history is twisting in the wind as swarms of photographers, rivaling the Jacob’s Field gnats, invade the lawn of his Harrison, N.Y., home. He deserves better.
Talk already has turned to who will succeed Torre. Three names at the forefront are bench coach Don Mattingly, Yankees broadcaster Joe Girardi and St. Louis Cardinals manager Tony La Russa. None of these choices would do a better job than Torre. None would even come close.
Mattingly may be the Yankees manager someday. He was a great Yankees player and an even better captain. But despite working under Torre as hitting coach and bench coach, Mattingly has never managed on any level. He needs a few more seasons to, well, season.
What about Girardi? He did an outstanding job as the Florida Marlins manager in 2006, helping a young, inexperienced team make some noise in the NL East. Girardi was named the NL Manager of the Year before being unceremoniously fired. Why? He got into an argument with Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria. Loria was screaming at an umpire from the stands during a game and Girardi politely told him to shut up. It cost him his job.
Arguing with ownership won’t fly in New York with the Boss, George Steinbrenner, peering over his shoulder, second-guessing every decision. If Girardi can’t get along with Loria, he’ll last about a week in the Bronx.
Girardi’s handling of some of his young pitchers in Florida also raised eyebrows. He caught heat for bringing pitcher Josh Johnson back into a game after a long rain delay. Johnson blew out his elbow. How would Girardi fare with the “Joba Rules” or managing Yankees future ace Philip Hughes?
Finally, La Russa’s name has been tossed around as a replacement for Torre. La Russa’s hiring would certainly make a splash. He’s a Hall of Fame manager and a marquee name. He has rings and he wants more. But La Russa’s temper and his stubbornness would not be a good fit with the Yankees. Much of Torre’s success has been due to his steady demeanor and his unwavering calm in the face of turbulence. Torre knew what he was getting into working for Steinbrenner. He takes the cartoon-like missives issued from Steinbrenner’s PR company in stride. He made it look easy. Could La Russa’s ego handle constantly being in the hot seat?
Torre’s managing numbers are incredible. Notching 10 division titles, six pennants and four world championships puts Torre among baseball history’s elite managers. Surviving 12 years of the Boss’ bluster puts him on top. True, he hasn’t guided the Yankees to a World Series win since 2000, but he’s guided them to two World Series appearances and into the playoffs every year since.
Ironically, Torre may have managed his best this year, guiding the Yankees back from a 14½ game deficit in the AL East to a wild card berth. He brought up young players like Hughes, Joba Chamberlain and Shelly Duncan, merging them seamlessly with the veteran superstars.
More and more Yankees players are saying Torre should stay. On Wednesday, Mariano Rivera said Torre’s retention or dismissal would have a major impact on his decision whether to re-sign with the Yankees. Andy Pettitte has said it all along. Torre’s fate could also impact Alex Rodriguez and Jorge Posada’s off-season decisions too.
Firing Torre would be change for changes sake. Steinbrenner needs to understand not all change’s are positive. He should release Torre from purgatory and bring him back to manage the New York Yankees. Nobody does it better.